Concepts of historical memory of Kryashen in Tatarstan: elitists versions of history and collective memory

Author(s): 
Abstract: 
The article considers how ethnic entrepreneurs, manipulating various historical facts, formed opposing versions of the history of the origin of the Kryashen or Baptized Tatars in Tatarstan. The author describes the concepts of the historical memory of Kryashen, everyday ideas of Kryashen about history, as well as popular versions of the origin of baptized Tatars, which are supported by the population of the republic. The study is based on the analysis of textbooks on the history of the Tatar people, popular science literature, and the mass media, narratives from 170 interviews and questionnaire data from Kazan. An analysis of the data shows that at the level of mass representations, the most popular is the version promoted by the main political player, the elite of the republic: the Kryashens appeared as a result of the forced baptism of the Tatars in the 16th century. A popular version among the Kryashens themselves is that the Kryashens were never part of the Tatar people, because they were never Muslims. The study shows that at the level of the elite discourse the unity of the Tatar people is declared and the differences between the Tatars and the Kryashens are leveled. However, at the level of everyday interaction, the Tatars did not observe the same attitude towards the Kryashens.
Keywords: 
collective memory
ethnic group
Kryashen
Kryashen problem
Pages: 
10-16
File: 
PDF icon 2019-5-03.pdf
doi: 

10.33491/telescope2019.5-601

References: 
  • Anderson B. (2001) Imaginary Communities. M .: Canon-Press-Ts. (In Russ.)
  • Bart F. (eds.) (2006) Ethnic groups and social boundaries. Social organization of cultural differences. M .: New Publishing House. (In Russ.)
  • Gallyamova A.G., Ivanov A.A., Piskarev V.I., Sultanbekov P.M. (2009) History of Tatarstan and the Tatar people. XX - beginning of XXI century. Textbook for grade 11 of educational institutions. - Kazan: Hether (TARIH). (In Russ.)
  • Dunaeva T. (2012) Maxim Glukhov and the problems of studying the history of Kryashen // Tuganailar. November 30th. (In Russ.)
  • Iskhakov D. (2002) A look at the All-Russian census from Tatarstan // AbImperio. No. 4 - P. 235-250. (In Russ.)
  • Iskhakov D.M.(2014) Baptized Tatars // Volga Star. March 8th. (In Russ.)
  • Iskhakov D.M. (2010) Tatars: Census and Politics - Kazan: Tatar Publishing House. (In Russ.).
  • Iskhakov D.M.  (2005) Tatars: popular ethnography (ethnic history of the Tatar people) - Kazan: Tatar.kiz.izd-vo. (In Russ.)
  • Iskhakov R.R. (2013) Sources // Tuganailar. October 28th. (In Russ.)
  • Iskhakov R.R. (2013) Religious beliefs and Orthodox institutions in baptized Tatars and Nagaybaks // History of the Tatars from ancient times in seven volumes. Volume 6. The formation of the Tatar nation of the 19th and early 20th centuries. Kazan. P. 434-494. (In Russ.)
  • Iskhakov R.R. (2012) Christian enlightenment and religious movements (re-Islamization) of baptized Tatars in the 19th - early 20th centuries. Collection of materials and documents / Comp., Author of the introductory article, notes, scientific and reference apparatus R.R. Iskhakov. - Kazan: Ihlas Publishing House; Institute of History Sh. Mardzhani AN RT. P. 3-25. (In Russ.)
  • Karbainov N.I. (2018) Images of the history of “Turkic civilization” in post-Soviet Tatarstan: elite versions and mass representations. Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology. 21 (2): 45-74. (In Russ.)
  • Lotfullin I.M., Islaev F.G. (2018) Jihad of the Tatar people. The heroic struggle of Muslim Tatars with the Orthodox Inquisition on the example of the history of the newly baptized office. Kazan. (In Russ.)
  • Maksimov N. (2014) No liquidation of the Kryashen people // Tuganailar. March 28. (In Russ.)
  • Malov M. (2012) Tribunal for a hero with a happy ending // Tuganailar. November 30th. (In Russ.)
  • Young rattles in Tatarstan: “We do not expect anything good from the census” // “Regnum” [http://www.regnum.ru/news/polit/1314867.html#ixzz367mn7zY3], 2010, August 13. The site was visited 06/27/2014. (In Russ.)
  • Mullina I. (2012) Ilminsky - Apostle of the Volga region // Tuganailar. July 6. (In Russ.)
  • The national composition of the population of the Republic of Tatarstan // Site of the Territorial Authority of the Federal State Statistics Service for the Republic of Tatarstan [http://www.tatstat.ru/VPN2010/DocLib8/%ED%E0%F6%20%F1%EE%F1%F2%E0 % E2.pdf], the site was visited on 06/28/2014. (In Russ.)
  • What the “Kryashen word” newspaper wrote about // Tuganailar. 2014, April 30th. (In Russ.)
  • Sokolovsky S. (2002) “The Tatar Problem” in the All-Russian Population Census // AbImperio. No. 4. P. 207-234. (In Russ.)
  • Suleymanov R. (2013) Kryashensky national movement at the present stage: the confrontation of Tatarization and Islamization // National self-determination Kryashen: history and modernity. Materials of the third public readings of the scientist-kryashenoved M.S. Glukhov, dedicated to his 75th birthday (November 23, 2012, Kazan). - Kazan: Yur-Card. P. 75-85. (In Russ.)
  • Filippov A.S. (2009) Heroes are grunted. From the series “The Golden Fund Kryashen.” - Kazan: The Word. (In Russ.)
  • Fokin A. (2013) Kryashen as an object of national policy // National self-determination of Kryashen: history and modernity. Materials of the third public readings of the scientist-kryashenoved M.S. Glukhov, dedicated to his 75th birthday (November 23, 2012, Kazan). - Kazan: Yur-Card. P. 86-104. (In Russ.)
  • Halbwax M.  (2005) Collective and historical memory // The untouchable reserve. No. 2-3 (40-41). P. 8-27. (In Russ.)
  • Shnirelman V. (2002) Identity and images of ancestors: Tatars before a choice. Bulletin of Eurasia. 4: 128–147. (In Russ.)
  • Assmann A. Transformations between history and memory // Social Research. 2008, 1(75): 49-72
  • Brubaker R. Ethnicity without groups. Harvard Un.Press, 2004.
  • Русский